Well ladies and gentlemen, another Academy Award season has come and gone thus officially ending Award Season for a while. Of course there was a lot of pomp and circumstance that came with the show and of course a lot of controversy. There is always a group of people that is unhappy with the results of the show and who won and who did not more importantly. There has been a lot said about the lack of African-American presence at this years Academy Award show. Of course this is a hot button community and I agree that there have been a lot of great African-American performances that have been overlooked. One that comes to mind is The Color Purple back in 1985 that received numerous nominations but did not win. Denzel Washington lost for playing Malcolm X to Al Pacino for Scent of A Woman and Angela Bassett for her spot on Tina Turner portrayal (considered to be front runner as she won the Golden Globe) lost to Holly Hunter for The Piano. There have been a lot of snubs for us, most recently David Oyelowo for Best Actor and Ava DuVernay for Best Director for the movie Selma. I certainly agree both deserved Oscar nominations. They definitely did.
Here is where my problem lies. Over the last few months I have seen a lot of shade being thrown at the performances that have won and at our current television shows that feature African-Americans in lead roles. Recently I saw a picture (picture to the left) that showed the few African-American women that have won Academy Awards and I have to admit I disagree with the message. Halle Berry was criticized for some said, “Playing a whore…” I must have seen a different version of Monster’s Ball because the version I saw Halle played a grieving mother who was acting out due to the loss of her son, and her baby’s father who died on death row. She had a graphic sex scene with Billy Bob Thorton and she was scrutinized well her performance rather because this was after all the first African-American woman to win and she had to take her clothes off that was the controversy. Denzel who won previously a Best Supporting Actor Academy Award for his role as a soldier in Glory finally won for his brilliant portrayal of Alonso, a rogue crooked cop in Training Day. The argument here was he was overlooked for Malcolm X, and The Hurricane but finally won for playing a thug. The point that people are missing is that Denzel played against type. Never had Denzel played a role like this. Denzel had played the hero, desperate father, leader, soldier, husband, and martyr but never had he played a villain and he played the hell out of the part. We hated Denzel after that because of his evilness. Why not award him with the Oscar? It was a great performance. Yes, he should’ve won for Malcolm but what was wrong with Training Day?
Similar arguments were said about Monique for playing the abusive, disturbed Mary in Precious. “She was an abusive mother!” that was the argument. “She was on welfare.” They continued. Again, I feel like the point was missed. Monique for one played against character. She was not known for playing dramatic roles, she was a comedienne. Her part was so stunning and haunting. Why are we critiquing this? Even Jamie Fox was recently insulted on a comment page earlier today for portraying music icon Ray Charles in Ray Fox was critiqued for playing a drug addicted, philandering, and difficult singer. Was that not Ray Charles? I do not understand. Jamie Fox nailed it as Ray Charles after many thought (due to his comedy background) he would not be able to pull it off. Whoopi Goldberg was even critiqued for winning Best Supporting Actress cause as the caption says she played a “Fake Psychic”in Ghost. Are you kidding me? What was degrading or negative about her performance? Without Goldberg’s performance, the movie would not have been as good. She carried that movie, hence her supporting actress win. It was the performance that won her that award.
We then complain about historic movies. We go, “I’m tired of us playing slaves.” “Not another civil rights movie….” Yet we are mad that Selma was snubbed out of several categories. Can we have it both ways? We complain about us playing maids and servants and supposed stereotypical roles but then we get Scandal, Empire, and How To Get Away With Murder shows not just with African-American women but African-American women in lead roles. All three shows are ratings powerhouses. All three actresses Kerry Washington, Viola Davis, and Taraji P. Henson play their parts with power, force, and complexity and at the same time vulnerability. They are powerful characters but they are flawed as well. Yet people are still not happy. We mad at Kerry cause she is having an affair with the white President. We mad at Viola because she is married to a white man and took her wig off, and we call Empire “coonery” (yes there was a critic who said that).
This to me is unfair. What exactly are we supposed to play? You don’t want to see slaves and maids or hookers or drug dealers yet we have these shows and you are still not happy. Of course the Cosby Show comparison comes out in which these shows are compared to them. Comparing these dramas to Cosby Show is comparing apples to oranges. Cosby was a sitcom not a drama. And while The Cosby Show remains one of my favorite shows; it’s not everyone’s reality. And since when is television supposed to be always about reality? Isn’t some entertainment supposed to be an escape? Are we as African-Americans not complex? Aren’t we flawed just like everyone else? Larry Hagman played the iconic yet ruthless J.R Ewing on Dallas for over 20 years. Heather Locklear played the powerful Amanda Woodard on Melrose Place who was flawed and made mistakes. Yet when we play these roles, its not good for our images? What??
It feels like we can’t win for loosing. Every role we play cannot be Sounder or The Cosby Show, A Different World or Raisin In The Sun. All this negative energy also takes away from the brilliant performances of our actors. We have a long way to go. I give you that. I agree with you that there a lot of images out there that portray us negatively. Have you seen reality television lately? We are critiquing these dramas but are somehow ok with Love & Hip Hop, Real Housewives of Atlanta, Flavor of Love, and countless reality shows that are actually reality (so they say). Those are real people. Yet we say nothing? We see our young men walk around with their pants sagging halfway around their ankles but we are angrier that Kerry Washington’s Olivia Pope is flawed? We are angry that Gabrielle Union in Being Mary Jane had an extra marital affair yet she is successful businesswoman? Something is wrong with this picture. At the end of the day Scandal and shows like it are about entertainment nothing else. Not every show is meant to change the world or have a message.
Do not get me wrong. I agree, there are a lot of things we need to improve on in our images on television and media but that does not mean we should be throwing shade at the ones out there who making things a little easier for those coming behind them. Hattie McDaniel played a maid but she was not a maid in real life. Had Hattie McDaniel not won, would the doors have been opened for others like say Dorothy Dandridge?
Let’s not get all bent out of shape on some of these entertainment shows. They are just that to entertain.












